Daniel

MMR does NOT cause Autism

There you go.  I've written it in black and white (or even a burnt orange colour if we're being pedantic).  The MMR vaccine does not cause autism.  Studies have proven this.  

One study, of only 12 children, supported the link between MMR and the increased risk of the development of autism.  This has been discredited by the scientific and medical experts.  However, none of the studies that prove the absence of a link have caused the media hysteria that accompanied this 'rogue' study.

I don't see front-page headlines in the press supporting and highlighting the proper scientific studies proclaiming "MMR does NOT cause autism", and  "Get your child vaccinated with the MMR jab and help prevent an outbreak of measles".

MMR provides protection against measles, mumps and rubella.  These can kill.  A child with measlesThat's why the vaccine is important.  Many parents opted for separate vaccinations against these three diseases, although that does increase the risk of the child contracting one of the other two diseases in the intervening period between injections.  Others have claimed that they don't have the option of the separate vaccinations, and so opted instead to not have their child vaccinated at all!  The result of this?  A massive increase in the number of measles cases in the UK.  

From the Evening Standard in August 2007: 

Parents have been urged to give their children the MMR vaccine as it was revealed Britain is in the middle of the worst measles outbreak for 20 years.  The unprecedented warning from the Health Protection Agency came as the number of children suffering from the disease trebled over the last 11 weeks.

Experts fear even more will be infected as the autumn school term begins.  This is the worst outbreak since the controversial MMR vaccine was introduced in 1988.

Take-up of the triple jab - which also protects against mumps and rubella - plummeted to 80 per cent after Dr Andrew Wakefield claimed it was linked to autism and bowel problems.

Leading scientists have since debunked Dr Wakefield's claims and rates of uptake are creeping back to recommended levels - except in London, where a quarter of children are still not vaccinated.
 

I've been discussing this topic on a number of forums (or is that fora?), and three parents with autistic children are firmly of the belief that MMR caused their children's autism.  Now I know it's an emotive subject, and I know they have been affected by their child's autism - but I still fail to see why they are so sure that it was caused by the MMR vaccination.

I asked them if that (now discredited) 'study' of 12 children hadn't taken place, and the press hysteria that accompanied it had also never happened, would there still be this resounding 'belief' that MMR causes autism?  What is the basis for this belief?

I'm still waiting for an answer.   One said that studies of 250 children weren't enough to disprove the link, although they seemed to be happy with a study of 12 children that did put forward the link.  I directed them to this study of a highly statistically significant sample, but they still aren't convinced.  There's also the Japanese study, where cases of autism continued to rise after MMR was banned.

It's reminds me of a blind faith that often accompanies a religious belief, such as fundamental Christians believing in creationism despite the overwhelming evidence that disproves it. 

8 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Did you see Derren Brown: The System? It was quite an interesting way of showing how we can be misled by our own narrow personal experience.

I didn’t see it Matt, but I have heard a lot of people discussing it.

Worth watching it if it’s repeated?

I once got food poisoning after holding the escalator rail at Waterloo station. I won’t be doing that again!

I played poker in Wales last month and came back with flu. So I’m not going to Wales again, and I’d advise you not to either.

Yeah it’s probably worth watching, although I reckon you’ll work out what’s going on pretty quickly.

well i have scan read your article and i feel that you are right but then why have autism rates gone up since MMR was introduced and you cannot say they havent because it is a scientific fact please email me back asap with your view of the this!! thanks emily.!.

Hi Emily.

Think you’re confusing causation and correlation.

Autism rates have increased for a number of reasons, one is probably the increase in detection.

Autism rates have continued to increase in Japan where MMR is banned!

http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn7076

more here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4311613.stm

There is a correlation between the number of pirates in the world and global temperatures. As the number of pirates has decreased, global temperatures have increased. I don’t think the reduction in the number of pirates is causing global warming though. It’s a scientific fact that global temperatures are increasing, and it’s also a fact that the number of pirates has decreased over the past two hundred years. I don’t think anyone would suggest that one has caused the other though as there is no evidence to link the two. There is as much evidence that MMR causes autism.



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)